Book Your Free Consultation

Comparision Chart

COMPANY Google RATING GUARANTEES MANAGEMENT FEE LEASING FEE YEARS IN BUSINESS
Penny Realty Logo 4.8 Star Rating
  • 4.8 Rating
  • 425 Google Reviews
  • 90 Day Money Back Guarantee + $500
  • 12 Month Lease
  • 30 Day Rental
  • Good Pet Guarantee
8%
*Discounts available for multiple properties.
No Leasing Fee Since 1965
Cal-Prop
Management Inc.
4.2 Star Rating
  • 4.2 RATING
  • 354 REVIEWS
No Guarantees 6.0% to 8%
Based on Gross Rentals
$500.00 Leasing Fee
$250.00 Renewal Fee
Since 1987
Utopia
Management
4.8 Star Rating
  • 4.4 RATING
  • 1,034 REVIEWS
  • Eviction Protection
  • Holistic Protection
8% No Leasing Fee Since 1994
Cairncross Property Management 3.3 Star Rating
  • 3.3 RATING
  • 21 REVIEWS
21 Day Rent Guarantee. 8-9% No Leasing Fee Since 1978
ONYX Property Management 4.4 Star Rating
  • 4.4 RATING
  • 133 REVIEWS
No Guarantees 8-10% No Leasing Fee SOS founded in 1998, but then changed it's name in 2001, due to bad reviews.
American Heritage
Properties
4.1 Star Rating
  • 4.1 RATING
  • 81 REVIEWS
Eviction Protection 7.5 to 10%
  • No Leasing Fee w/ 10% Management Fees
  • $200-$500 Leasing Fee with 7.5%-8.5% Management Fees Plus $65 Admin Fee
Since 1981
Sunset Property Management 4.3 Star Rating
  • 4.3 RATING
  • 107 REVIEWS
Eviction Protection
4½% LISTING
4-8%
  • $550.00 Leasing Fee
  • $150.00 Renewal Fee
  • Flat Fee Option
Since 2011
FBS Property Management 3.2 Star Rating
  • 3.2 RATING
  • 56 REVIEWS
No Guarantees 10%
  • $200 Origination Fee
  • $350 Leasing Fee
Since 1972
Shore Management Inc. 3.2 Star Rating
  • 3.2 RATING
  • 33 REVIEWS
No Guarantees 8% No Leasing Fee Since 1999
CS Property
Management
2.6 Star Rating
  • 2.6 RATING
  • 19 REVIEWS
No Guarantees 8 to 10% Based on Type of Property and Location No Leasing Fee Since 1990

Information is up to date as of 10-1-2025. We update this page periodically. If you feel this information is incorrect, please contact us at 858-272-3900.